What to get my bf for our 1 year anniversary and valentines day?

me and my bf dustin will be dating for a year on january 16th. i have no clue what to get him at all he absolutely loves football and basketball but i wanted to get something that has me and him in it and wont cost that much. he means alot to me. i have found something but idk if i want to get it for valentines day because i dont know what to get him there either. so if you guys can help i would really appreciate it thanks.